The Friday Face-Off: Metropolis

Welcome to The Friday Face-Off, a new weekly meme hosted by Books by Proxy. Join us every Friday as we pit cover against cover, and publisher against publisher, to find the best artwork in our literary universe.


The Friday Face-Off: Metropolis

Mitosis (Reckoners #1.5) by Brandon Sanderson

2219486219032892

asdf

asdf

asdf
asdf

VS.

asdf

asdf

asdf

asdf


 Delacorte Press – US Cover

19032892

Cover art by ???

◊  ◊  ◊

Gollancz – UK Cover

22194862

Cover art by Sam Green


 The Friday Face-Off Winner is…

22194862

Gollancz – UK Cover; Cover Art by Sam Green

Out of all the cover’s Sam Green has done for the Reckoner’s series, this one is my least favorite. It a little dull, and lacking action. I know that gray colors and sketching is supposed to make that aqua green stand out – and it does, and it looks amazing on all the other covers. But behind that main tower in the front, it’s only gray nothingness… I don’t know what should or could go there, but I’m no all too keen on it. Now that I look at it more though, that green slashing in from of the tower, does take my focus off the background gray. I still do like the cover, just not as immediately as Green’s other covers.

However, the US cover has “YA” written all over. The front, the cover art, the cover design. No way you can’t look at that and not think it’s a YA story. Not that there is anything wrong wit that, but I prefer the… mature(?),adult(?)… No, now that just sounds like something else XD I prefer the fantasy cover for books who aren’t market toward the YA crowd primary.

Which cover do you think is the best?

-DJ

Advertisements
Tagged , , ,

8 thoughts on “The Friday Face-Off: Metropolis

  1. Bookwraiths says:

    I totally agree with your pick and your reasoning for it. Then again, I always seem to prefer UK covers.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Have to agree with your choice, the UK cover looks far better, yay for the UK! 🙂

    Like

  3. @lynnsbooks says:

    Not so sure with this one – I think it’s a draw for me because there isn’t one that immediately stands out more than the other. I quite like the city skyline for the US one. The UK one looks like a game of chess somehow – that’s my immediate impression.
    Lynn 😀

    Like

  4. proxyfish says:

    Absolutely – the UK cover wins hands down (as Sam Green always will in my eyes!) I actually really love this illustration, it’s almost like a towering city of skyscrapers has burst up out of nothing and nowhere, I love the really simplistic colour scheme too with just a flash of teal.

    The US cover definitely seems a bit YA and a little too generic for my tastes. I probably wouldn’t even pick it up if it didn’t have Sanderson’s name sprawled across it! It reminds me of a cheap thriller.

    Like

  5. sjhigbee says:

    I love the UK Brandon Sanderson’s covers with the grey/green colouring and the delicate artwork and pared, spare look. It’s a smart move – I immediately know it’s a Sanderson book just with a fleeting glance. I’m interested to know whether there really is a cultural divide here – do US visitors to our sites mostly prefer US covers, whereas UK folks like the UK covers more?

    Like

  6. Not to be negative, but I’m not real crazy about either. I mean, I don’t dislike them, but I don’t really like either of them either.

    Like

  7. Hmm, this is a tough one. I would say it’s a tie, but tbh I don’t really like either one. The US cover looks tacky somehow, like it was cobbled together in photoshop but I also really dislike the artstyle of the UK cover. Seems from the comments I’m not the only one feeling torn, lol.

    Like

  8. Zezee says:

    The UK cover wins for me too although I don’t like it much. I agree with you about too much grey on it. Maybe I need to see it in person to see if it stands out.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: